You finally managed to save up some money and decided to invest it in one of the best pellet grills. But, with so many amazing models available, it can be very hard to decide which one should you get.
Traeger and Pit Boss make some of the most popular pellet grills on the market today. And, if you start asking around or reading reviews, you’ll get plenty of opinions. Every person will end up defending their grill and slamming the competition, so finding an objective opinion is a difficult task.
Each brand makes grills that have distinct features. Pit Boss grills tend to keep the natural flavors of the food intact, whereas Traeger is all about injecting your food with authentic barbecued flavors. Comparing both brands, in general, is a difficult task since each of their grills have specific features. That’s why we decided to give you first a brief comparison of the two brands and then we’ll focus on their most popular products.
When it comes to Pit Boss, it seems that buyers usually go for the Pit Boss 700FB Pellet Grill. However, one of the Traeger’s most popular models is the Pro Series 22 Pellet Grill and Smoker. Keep reading to find out the difference between these two models.
Pit Boss vs. Traeger Grills – Head to Head Comparison
Below we’ll walk through which grills are better on our key categories: price, grill design & construction, cooking space, pellet hopper size, temperature ranges, overall versatility, and a review of advanced and specialty features from each grill.
One of the features people are interested the most in is the price tag. Sometimes, your budget will have a significant impact on your decision. Both Pit Boss and Traeger offer high-quality models with similar features, but with different price tags.
If you are on a limited budget and the price is a determining factor, then Pit Boss will be a great choice for you. The manufacturer offers grills that cost from $300 to $700. And, according to many customer reviews, Pit Boss offers better value for money.
Traeger on the other hand offers more models to choose from. The majority of their models tend to cost over $1,000 but their price starts at about $500 and some models tend to cost over $1000. Those are usually very large grills with premium features. But, if you have high demands and budget, then Traeger will come out on top.
Grill Design and Construction
A feature that affects the performance of your grill the most is its construction. If you’re already planning to invest in a grill, it’s better to pay more money initially if the grill features superior construction because not only will the grill last you for years, but your food will be cooked evenly. Grills made of flimsy and lightweight materials are prone to rust, breaking down, and leaking heat which results in unevenly cooked food.
And, when it comes to grill build quality, few companies can beat Traeger. Their grills are made of high-quality, durable materials. Pit Boss, on the other hand, uses quality materials as well but some of their models are a bit flimsy when compared to Traeger.
Now when it comes to Traeger Pro Series 22 Pellet Grill and Smoker, it features a sturdy build, all-terrain wheels, and a sawhorse base. This means that you can move this grill anywhere and without much effort. More importantly, thanks to the quality build, this model is great at heat retention and cooking food evenly.
Pit Boss truly tried its best to make a grill that could beat this one, and they ended up with 700FB. Even though both models are made out of cast iron and feature porcelain-coated cooking grates that prevent food from sticking on the grill, the 700 FB hasn’t been able to match the Traeger Pro Series 22 convincingly.
In addition, what gives Traeger an upper hand is that the manufacturer used a non-toxic material in the grill that prevents the addition of any harmful substance in the food that is grilled on the grates.
Pit Boss certainly gave their best, but their grill ended up being simply a bit frailer than Traeger’s.
The second most important feature of the grill you should pay attention to is the cooking space. How much cooking space your grill has is going to determine how much time you will be spending cooking meals on the grill. The more space you have, the more food you can cook at the same time.
When speaking about all their grills in general, Traeger definitely surpasses Pit Boss because they offer many more models that feature from 300 to 1,300 square inches. Most of the Pit Boss grills feature 500 square inches of cooking space. There are models that offer more space (like the 700 FB), but these are often designed with a two-tiered cooking space.
Now when comparing the two bestsellers, the Pit Boss 700 FB and the Traeger Pro Series 22, Pit Boss is a clear winner in terms of the cooking space. You get a total of 700 square inches of cooking space on two levels for a more affordable price. Traeger’s model, on the other hand, offers 572 square inches of cooking space.
Keep in mind that 700 square inches is an excellent choice for love throwing large gatherings and cooking food for about ten people. If you belong to this category, then Pit Boss 700 FB is an excellent choice for you.
When it comes to Traeger, even though it offers a smaller cooking surface, 572 square inches is still enough to cook for five or more people at the same time. The total cooking space is enough for cooking four whole chickens, five racks of smoked ribs, and up to 24 burgers. We believe that this much space is just enough for the majority of people who love to cook for their family but also invite a few friends over.
Since we’re talking about pellet grills, it’s very useful to get the model which features a hopper with large capacity. The more pellets the hopper can hold, the more smoke you’ll get without needing to refill that container.
A hopper is a vital part of grills since it is in charge of disposing of the wood pellets which then burn to create smoke. Only then can the cooking process begin.
Pit Boss pellet grills usually feature hoppers that can hold up to 12 or even 14 pounds. Traeger grills are usually equipped with bigger hoppers. Some can hold up to 18 lbs. of wood pellets and they also feature a great system that helps to collect ash from the pellets. The Traeger Pro Series 22 is one of those smokers.
However, Pit Boss 700FB stands out when it comes to hopper capacity since it can hold up to 20 lbs. of wood pellets. Even though it is not too great of a difference when compared to the Traeger Pro Series 22, you still will get more hopper capacity for a more affordable price.
Temperature range is very important and it can help you decide whether a grill can fulfill all your needs. For example, if you want to sear food, you will need a grill that can be able to reach sizzling high temperatures and not all grills can do that.
Pit Boss grills offer an excellent temperature range from 170°F to 600°F. Such a wide range of temperature range encourages multiple types of cooking and with great precision. You can use this temperature range to grill your meat or veggies low and slow or you can go for the highest temperature which is perfect for searing.
On the other hand, Traeger grill can reach up to a temperature of 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which is good, but not as good as Pit Boss. You can use this grill to cook food at any temperature between 180°F and 450°F without having to worry about your food being under- or overcooked.
If you’re already investing a lot of money in a grill, then you probably want it to be as versatile as possible. Both Pit Boss and Traeger have models that come only with some standard features, but there are also those packing all different bells and whistles. The two products we are comparing are somewhere in between.
The Traeger Pro Series 22 is known as the 6-in-one model that will allow you to grill, smoke, sear, roast, and even bake. So, you can get a variety of food items cooked one of these ways without putting in too much of an effort.
Pit Boss 700FB is declared to be an 8-in-1 model. It allows users to bake, smoke, sear, char-grill, braise, roast, BBQ, and grill in one super-sleek grill. In reality, both of the models are very similar and you can use them to saute, stir-fry, cook breakfast, cook your dinner in just a few minutes.
In addition, both grills are very easy to use and are one of the set-it-and-forget-it models. When it comes to the Traeger, its automatic auger constantly monitors the heat and adds more wood pellets from the hopper as needed, which lets you walk away without worrying the temperature might change.
The Pit Boss 700FB operates similarly. Just load the woodchips, choose the desired temperature, and within 10 minutes the grill will automatically light the pellets and reach the selected temperature.
Let’s face it; buying a bulky and expensive grill is no fun at all if it isn’t capable of getting you a perfectly grilled food unless you babysit. Luckily, both Pit Boss and Traeger equip all of their grills with some unique features.
In Pit Boss, you get a digital temperature control to monitor the temperature inside the grill. You can easily specify the type of cooking and the burn length. This is a ‘set and forget’ kind of grill where you will have to add the wood pellet into the hopper, select the temperature and relax. The smoker will take care of the rest.
Traeger has all of that but also one more feature that makes it slightly better than the Pit Boss grills. Traeger grills feature an advanced digital controller that will help you maintain precise temperatures within +/- 15 degrees.
Cleaning & Maintenance
Sometimes, owning the best grill ever made is not worth it if you have to spend hours cleaning and maintenance. How does dozing off on your bed and not indulging yourself in the annoying and messy grill cleaning process sound to you? Impossible? Well, not really. Both Pit Boss and Traeger made sure that all of their models are easy to clean and maintain.
Both manufacturers make porcelain-coated grids which ensure that the food won’t get stuck on them. Cleaning these grates is incredibly easy; just wipe them off with soapy water and you’ll be good to go. However, there are small differences when it comes to cleaning the rest of the grill.
Pit Boss grills come with a grease bucket where all the grease accumulates. So, all you need to is remove the bucket and throw that grease into the trash can. Traeger, on the other hand, provided a tray on the bottom of the unit where all the grease will accumulate and cleaning it is as simple as cleaning the Pit Boss grills.
When it comes to cleaning and maintenance, there is no real winner. Both manufacturers thought of their customers and decided to make their lives easier by coming up with grills that are simple to clean.
Warranty is an incredibly important feature of all products, especially pricy ones. Even if you take care of your grill and maintain it properly, it can still break down. Buying a grill that has a multiple-year warranty will add confidence in users that if anything happens to the product, they will not be charged heavily for the repair or replacement of the part(s).
Pit Boss grills are covered by a one-year warranty, so if anything happens to the grill after 365 days, you will be the one paying for that. Traeger grills, on the other hand, come with a three-year warranty, allowing you to explore your grilling skills to full potential without worrying much about the product breaking down.
Should I Buy Pit Boss or Traeger?
Both brands are known for making quality grills that will last you for years. Our goal is not to decide a winner but to give you an in-depth review of the features of grills and help you decide which brand is more suitable for your needs.
If you are a pitmaster who loves and plans to smoke plenty of food frequently, then Pit Boss 700FB is an excellent choice for you, thanks to the large cooking space and hopper capacity. If you would rather get a smaller yet pricier grill which is a bit sturdier, then Traeger is the way to go.
Pit Boss – What Type of Buyer Will Prefer This Product?
Pit Boss 700FB is an excellent choice for all those who love tasting that natural smoky flavor in their food. This grill will keep the natural smoky flavor of the food intact and you can also experiment with different wood chips flavors.
Also, it is suitable for all those who are looking for an affordable grill that is made of quality materials and will not wear down quickly.
Last but not least, Pit Boss is suitable for grill enthusiasts with diverse needs. The grills are perfect for large gatherings, but you can also use it for your family only. All Pit Boss grills are very versatile and will allow you to cook food in many different ways.
Traeger – What Type of Buyer Will Prefer This Product?
Traeger grills come in many different sizes, so, whether you plan to use your grill for large gatherings or only for cooking for your family, you will find a model for your needs.
Since Traeger grills are known for their quality performance, their bigger models are suitable for BBQ competitions or even those who are running a small food business. You will be able to cook smoky and scrumptious foods that will leave everyone wanting more.
But, just because Traeger grills are so advanced, that doesn’t mean novice smokers can’t use them. If you’ve just taken up grilling as your hobby, then you will love Traeger grills since they do most of the work. The only thing you will have to do is add wood pellets and put your food in.
After reading this thorough comparison of the industry’s top two brands, we hope that you feel more confident about making the final decision.
Each brand comes with certain advantages and disadvantages, but, as you could see, Traeger and Pit Boss have a lot more in common than they have differences. The most significant difference is the size of the grills and the price tag. Traeger grills tend to be more expensive, but there are more models available to choose from. In terms of quality and performance, both brands offer high-quality models that will ensure excellent cooking results every time.